The
Purest
Dairy

CONTACT US
creamline
non homogenized
100% Jersey
A2A2

Who We Are

Bethel Creamery began with a simple mission: to bring uncompromising quality back to dairy. What started as a small, local effort has grown into a trusted creamery known for its dedication to purity, craftsmanship, and integrity. From careful sourcing to meticulous production, we uphold standards rooted in tradition while embracing the best of modern innovation.

Every product we create reflects our belief that dairy should be honest, clean, and truly delicious. Today, Bethel Creamery continues to honor its founding vision—delivering premium dairy that our customers can rely on, day after day.

Featured Products

Product Image

Whole Milk Vanilla Leben Yogurt

Grass Fed Whole Milk Leben MORE INFO
Product Image

Blueberry Greek Yogurt

Grass Fed Whole Milk MORE INFO
Product Image

A2A2 Chocolate Milk

Whole Grass Fed MORE INFO
Product Image

Greek Maple Yogurt

Grass Fed Whole Milk MORE INFO
Product Image

Plain Greek Yogurt

Grass Fed Whole Milk MORE INFO
Product Image

Vanilla Bean Greek Yogurt

Grass Fed Whole Milk MORE INFO
Product Image

Whole Milk Chocolate Leben Yogurt

Grass Fed Whole Milk Leben MORE INFO
Product Image

Whole Milk Plain Leben Yogurt

Grass Fed Whole Milk Leben MORE INFO
Nutrition Information

Contact us

    Thank you for your submission!

    We will contact you as soon as possible.

    Call 845-320-3599 Location 526 Happy Ave, Swan Lake, NY 12783

    Customer Feedback

    Just had not 1 but 3 Kosher Bethel yogurts that I bought in Sunflower grocery and It was absolutely delicious! This is how yogurt (and everything) is meant to be! without a ton of artificial junk and preservatives.

    Ab Gold

    I’ve never had better yogurt. The milk gets cream at the top when stored like “real” milk should. I hope the goats work well for you, cow milk products are out of this world. I’ll make the drive to go get some anytime I’m over the bridge in NY.

    Andrew Loniak

    My family and I LOVE this place!!! We keep coming back again and against for the freshest most wholesome milk, chocolate milk yogurts, cheese. Loved the cafe food this summer! Can’t wait for
    another visit! 😀

    Ephrat

    Share Your Experience